Planning a project

Should you repair your roof or replace it?

Short answer

Repair when the damage is limited to one area and the rest of the roof is in good shape. Consider replacement when the roof is near the end of its expected life, problems are showing up in several places, or repairs keep coming back. A poorly installed roof may need replacing even when it's fairly new. A free estimate tells you which applies to your roof.

Not every leak means you need a new roof. Not every roof is worth patching, either. The decision comes down to the roof’s age, how widespread the damage is and how long you plan to stay in the house.

When a repair makes sense

  • The damage is in one area, for example after a storm or a fallen branch
  • The roof is well within its expected lifespan
  • The problem is at a detail, like flashing around a chimney, a vent or a skylight
  • The rest of the roof is sound when inspected

Signs it may be time to replace

  • The roof is near or past its expected life for the material (see how long a roof lasts)
  • Shingles are curling, cracking or missing across large areas
  • Heavy granule loss: bald patches on shingles, granules piling up in eavestroughs
  • Leaks in several places, or repairs that keep failing
  • A sagging roofline or soft spots in the deck
  • Daylight or moisture visible in the attic
  • The roof was poorly installed (see below)

When poor workmanship can’t be repaired

Sometimes a roof has to be replaced even though it is well within its expected life, because it was installed so poorly that it can’t be fixed.

A striking example is a cedar roof put on with the wrong type of nails. Every so often we see fairly new cedar roofs, around 10 years old, where shingles start falling off. The nails have simply rusted through. There is nothing you can do to save a roof like that: more and more shingles will come off every month, and the only real fix is a new roof installed with the right fasteners.

Questions worth asking yourself

  • How long will you stay? If you plan to stay for many years, replacing an ageing roof now avoids paying for repairs and then a replacement anyway.
  • Is the damage hiding something bigger? Water that has been getting in for a while can rot the deck underneath, which only shows when the roofing comes off.
  • Do you want a different material? Replacement is the chance to move to a longer-lasting roof, or to add insulation and ventilation.

Heritage and premium roofs are different

Slate, copper and cedar roofs can often be repaired or restored rather than replaced. Individual slates can be swapped out, and copper details can be restored. A slate roof that looks tired is often far from finished. See restoring a heritage roof.

Get an honest assessment

We look at your roof and tell you plainly whether a repair will do the job. If replacement makes more sense, we explain why and give you a written estimate. In most cases we can see everything we need from the ground. Toronto roofs are often steep and hard to get onto, but steep roofs are easy to see from the street. When the situation isn’t clear, we may also check the attic or use a drone. Estimates are free. If you’d like us to get up on the roof for a full inspection, that’s a separate service with a fee that depends on the roof.

By Royal York Roofing · Updated

Book your free estimate

We look at your roof, explain your options and give you a written, no-obligation quote.