Choosing a roof

3-tab, architectural or designer shingles: which should you choose?

Short answer

Traditional 3-tab shingles have been discontinued, so today you choose between architectural and designer shingles. Architectural shingles are thicker and stand up better to wind and ice. Designer shingles are the thickest, premium option, textured to look like slate or wood. Both carry a limited lifetime manufacturer warranty, and a well-installed shingle roof realistically lasts 20 to 30 years.

Asphalt shingles are the most common roof on Toronto homes. They’re cost-effective, cope well with Canada’s temperature swings and come in a wide range of colours and styles. The main decision is which type of shingle to choose.

Traditional 3-tab (discontinued)

For years, 3-tab was the most affordable option for sloped roofs. It has a flat, even look that suits low-pitch roofs, and it usually came with a 25- or 30-year manufacturer warranty. Because it has been discontinued, repairing a 3-tab roof means finding the closest match from another product.

Architectural shingles

The standard choice for most homes today.

  • An extra layer of thickness for strength and durability
  • Holds to the roof better than 3-tab shingles did
  • Stands up better to ice and snow, and is harder for high winds to tear away
  • Costs less than designer shingles
  • Limited lifetime manufacturer warranty

Designer shingles

The premium shingle.

  • The thickest and most durable shingle option
  • A textured, layered look that recreates the depth of natural slate or wood shakes
  • Limited lifetime manufacturer warranty

Designer shingles are a good middle ground if you love the look of slate, but your budget or roof structure isn’t right for the real thing.

Colour and shape

Once you’ve picked the type, you choose a colour and texture. Colours range from greys and beiges to reds and dark browns, plus blues and greens. Shape matters too: scalloped tabs suit Victorian homes, while square, slate-like shingles suit Colonial designs.

Our advice

For most Toronto homes we recommend a quality architectural shingle. Consider designer shingles if curb appeal is a priority or the house’s style calls for a slate or shake look. Whichever you choose, expect a well-installed shingle roof to last 20 to 30 years. The manufacturer’s limited lifetime warranty covers defects in the material, and our written workmanship warranty covers the installation.

By Royal York Roofing · Updated

Book your free estimate

We look at your roof, explain your options and give you a written, no-obligation quote.