Short answer
For most flat roofs in Toronto we recommend a two-ply modified bitumen system. It handles hot summers and cold, icy winters, lasts around 20 to 25 years (up to 30 with added protection), and is clean to install and easy to repair. Tar and gravel lasts about as long but is messier, smells during installation and is harder to repair. TPO and EPDM usually last a little under 20 years in our cold climate, so we install them only when a customer specifically needs them.
A flat roof has a pitch of 10° or less. Flat roofs are common on Toronto homes, additions, garages and commercial buildings, and more people are turning them into usable space.
Our recommendation: two-ply modified bitumen
About 95% of the flat roofs we install are two-ply modified bitumen. We believe it is the best choice for the Canadian climate, with its hot summers and cold winters full of ice and snow. In our experience it has proven to be the most reliable and longest-lasting flat roof system.
Modified bitumen is asphalt reinforced and modified for flexibility. It goes on in two layers, a base sheet and a cap sheet, which gives two lines of defence against water. It is tough and handles foot traffic well.
It also has practical advantages:
- Clean installation. No kettles of hot tar and no layer of gravel on top.
- Easy to inspect and repair. Holes, cracks and worn spots are easy to see on the bare surface, so they can be found and fixed quickly.
- A longer working life. Because problems are easy to find, the roof can be maintained for longer, and you can often get a few extra years out of it even after it starts to leak.
A properly installed two-ply roof lasts around 20 to 25 years, and up to 30 years with added protection.
Tar and gravel
Tar and gravel (also called four-ply or built-up roofing) is still used, though much less often than it used to be. It lasts about as long as two-ply modified bitumen, but it has some downsides:
- Messy installation. It is built up from several layers of hot tar and felt.
- Strong smell. The hot tar gives off a strong odour during installation, which many customers don’t like.
- Harder to repair. The finished roof is covered with a layer of gravel embedded in tar. When the roof eventually starts to leak from normal wear, or is accidentally damaged, the gravel hides the problem, so the leak is much harder to find and fix.
TPO and EPDM
TPO (thermoplastic polyolefin) is a single-ply membrane, usually white or light grey, with heat-welded seams. EPDM is a single-ply synthetic rubber membrane, usually black.
Both are widely used, but in our cold climate they usually last a little under 20 years, even when properly installed. We install TPO and EPDM when a customer specifically needs them.
What matters as much as the material
- Drainage. Water pooling on a flat roof is the most common cause of problems. Drains, scuppers and a slight slope need to move water off quickly.
- Edges and penetrations. Most leaks start where the roof meets a wall, drain, skylight, vent or HVAC unit, not in the middle of the roof.
- Insulation. Re-roofing is the best time to add insulation under the new roof.
Using your flat roof
A flat roof can become a deck, a patio, a rooftop garden or even a greenhouse. It’s also a convenient place for HVAC equipment, and it gets sun all day, which suits solar panels. If you’re planning any of these, tell us before the roof goes on, so the roofing and protection layers can be chosen for the extra weight and foot traffic.
Maintenance
Have a flat roof checked at least once a year. Clear debris from the drains, and look for pooling water, blisters or cracks. Small repairs on a flat roof are inexpensive; water that has been getting in for a season is not.